Am I bi with a preference for women or a lesbian?

Questions and discussion about your sexuality and how it's a part of who you are as a person.
vry_confused
newbie
Posts: 2
Joined: Sun Nov 15, 2026 8:07 pm
Age: 20
My pronouns: She/they
My sexual identity and orientation: Questioning
Location: CA

Am I bi with a preference for women or a lesbian?

Post by vry_confused »

Hi, for the longest time I’ve considered myself bi. I’ve dated exactly one woman and one man, both of which were quite a few years ago. I’ve been pretty confident in my sexuality until this past week or so because I’m slowly coming to the possible realization that I may only be sexually attracted to men and not romantically, but romantically and sexually attracted to women. The past few romantic opportunities I’ve had have been with men and every time I figure “yeah, I’m into him because I’d have sex with him” however, the moment they get romantic or too flirty, I completely shut down and am completely turned off to the situation. Then there’s the fact that every time I think about settling down with a man, I think of how I’m scared I’d regret not settling down with a woman, but not visa versa. I’ve always been confident about my attraction to men, but I’ve only ever had one semi successful relationship with a man when I was in high school (who I was very much in love with at the time) and even then I had my moment of “oh god, do I actually want this?” with him. The thought of being with a woman makes me feel giddy and excited, but being with a man only makes me a different kind of excited. What is going on with me??
Becky
scarleteen staff/volunteer
Posts: 187
Joined: Fri Jan 19, 2024 5:29 pm
Age: 33
My primary language: English
My pronouns: She/They
My sexual identity and orientation: Queer
Location: USA

Re: Am I bi with a preference for women or a lesbian?

Post by Becky »

Hey vry_confused! Welcome to the boards!

I have to be very honest with you. We're not the biggest fans of labels here at Scarleteen.

Not because they can't be useful! But because the world we live in seems very obsessed with making people pick a label and then sticking to it-- never to change or be discussed again. The reality is that human sexuality can be very fluid and our experience of it can change and vary greatly over the course of our lifetime. Our society's understanding of the labels we have available to us are also pretty limited. For example, do you believe that because you are only interested in men sexually and not romantically that you can't identify as bisexual? Bisexual just means you have the capacity to be attracted to more than one gender! It doesn't mean you have to experience these attractions equally. There are many bisexual people who have a preference for one gender over another for various reasons.

Someone's whose experience might resonate with you is Dr. Melissa Fabello. She was one of my professors in grad school and does a lot of online work about the nuances of bisexuality. I like this article of hers in particular because it references the OBI model. The Orientation, Behavior, and Identity model was created by another of my professors, Dr. Brent Satterly. It is a framework that allows for a lot more nuance and complexity in our experiences of sexuality as humans. You can check out the article here: If You’re Not Sure You’re ‘Allowed’ to Identify as Bisexual, Read This

Obviously, we can't answer this question for you. Only you know the true experience of your sexuality and attraction and only you get to define it-- if you even want to define it at all. But if you'd like to hear from some other members of Scarleteen who have experience questioning their sexuality and the boxes we can find ourselves in, we have some awesome articles right here on our website:

Straight, Gay and Everything in Between: On Sexual Fluidity
Q is for Questioning
The Answers (For Now)

We're also always here to talk things through with you! Let me know what you think after reading these articles :)
“All of us have to learn how to invent our lives, make them up, imagine them. We need to be taught these skills; we need guides to show us how. If we don't, our lives get made up for us by other people.” -- Ursula K. Le Guin
vry_confused
newbie
Posts: 2
Joined: Sun Nov 15, 2026 8:07 pm
Age: 20
My pronouns: She/they
My sexual identity and orientation: Questioning
Location: CA

Re: Am I bi with a preference for women or a lesbian?

Post by vry_confused »

Hi, Becky! Thank you so much for your input and the articles you linked, they actually helped me tons. I think I’ve just gone on for so long thinking sexuality had to be clear cut, black and white, and had to be labeled, that I never considered the possibility that maybe labels aren’t for me or that there were more levels to it than the strict definition of each label. I think part of my need for clear cut labels is my ocd (very real and diagnosed). I’ve always held the belief that if you were bisexual, you had romantic and sexual feelings for men, women, and other genderqueer identities. However, as I’ve come to realize in my initial post, that is not the case. In reading those articles you linked, I’ve learned a lot about myself and about how labels aren’t clear cut (and how they can’t be). I think I’m so used to being on the internet and having everyone policing identities, that I never stopped to consider that I don’t have to be labeled to be accepted into the community. Thank you again for your reply, reading through what you and the articles had to say really helped to calm the storm in my head.
Andy
scarleteen staff/volunteer
Posts: 642
Joined: Sun Jan 02, 2022 3:24 pm
Age: 23
My pronouns: She/they
My sexual identity and orientation: queer
Location: Czech Repulic

Re: Am I bi with a preference for women or a lesbian?

Post by Andy »

Hi vry_confused,

I am so so glad to hear what Becky said and the articles have been so helpful in realising all this! And that is was a relief for you to find that out. If you would like to read more on this from others and from people struggling with similar issues, you can find a couple of conversations about that happening around the boards.

And I just want to echo that any place policing identities, where you feel pressured into using specific ways to call yourself, is just generally not a good space to be in, for you or anyone else in it. You will definitely be able to find other spaces and people where there is no such pressure or expectation.
Post Reply Previous topicNext topic
  • Similar Topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post